Corporate bond yields are at or near record lows as investors plow into CCC and even unrated debt. Will record optimism be rewarded?
This article was originally published by Mish Talk.
Bond Yield Ratings
- AAA bond the highest grade investment bonds
- BBB variants are the lowest investment-grade bonds
- CCC bond variants encompass extremely speculative all the way to default imminent.
- BofA High Yield Index: 4.16
- BofA BBB Index: 2.24
- BofA CCC or Lower Index: 7.30
- Moody’s 20+ Year AAA Seasoned: 2.55
- 10-Year US Treasury: 1.28
- BofA AAA Index: 1.81
- The record low CCC yield was last month at 6.77%
- The record low BBB yield was 2.12 in December of 2020.
- The record low High Yield Index was last month at 4.02%
We are at or near the record lows across the most speculative indices.
Bond Yield Spreads
- The spread between high yield and BBB is 1.93 percentage points. It was much lower in May of 2007 at 1.35 percentage points.
- The AAA 20+ spread over the 10-year US treasury appears to be in a normal range, currently at 1.27 percentage points.
Spreads however are a bit misleading because they mask absolute yields.
For example, although the High Yield to BBB spread fell to 1.35 percentage points,the BBB Index was at least 5.96% vs 2.24% now.
But not even that nearly 6% yield save BBB bonds in housing bubble bust.
In November of 2008, the BBB yield soared to 9.91%
Index quality and duration are also factors. Some suggest the quality of junk is better now than then. The WSJ comments “54% of bonds in the ICE BofA U.S. high-yield index carry an average double-B credit rating, the highest ratings tier below investment grade. That is up from 47% two years ago and 38% in 2008, just before the financial crisis.”
Also consider Ford: Fitch Affirms Ford and Ford Credit’s IDRs at ‘BB+’
Ford has $152 billion in total debt. That debt is just one notch below investment grade.
But will Ford survive?
Search for Yield Leads Bond Buyers to Unrated Debt
The WSJ reports Search for Yield Leads Bond Buyers to Unrated Debt.
Faced with yields once reserved for the safest types of government debt, some managers of speculative-grade bond funds are piling into debt with rock-bottom credit ratings. Others are buying smaller, more obscure securities that carry higher yields because they can be hard to sell.
The average speculative-grade U.S. corporate bond yield reached as low as 3.53% this summer, more than a percentage point lower than it had reached at any time before the Covid-19 pandemic, according to Bloomberg Barclays data stretching back to 1995.
For much of the year, many have been piling into the lowest-rated speculative-grade bonds—those rated triple-C or lower. This buying spree has driven yields down so far that purchasers have rarely been compensated less for taking risk.
Marc Bushallow, a portfolio manager at Manning & Napier Inc., based in the Rochester, N.Y., area, is among those adopting a different strategy. Since last fall, the firm’s seven-person fixed-income team has been pursuing smaller, less frequently traded corporate bonds that are often unrated by the three major ratings firms.
“There are times in the market when you want to own less-liquid stuff, and there are times when you don’t,” he said. “It’s relatively early in the [economic] cycle, so unless you think the cycle is going to end in 12 to 18 months, we think that it is still a pretty attractive place to be.”
Early or Late?
I am amused by the comment that it’s “relatively early in the cycle”. Early or late, yields are at or near record lows.
GDP estimates are falling like a rock and everything is priced for perfection.
Even if there is no recession on the horizon, junk bond yields can rise for all kinds of reasons, one of them being a simple attitude change over what constitutes reasonable risk.